Andersen Dealer vs. Renewal by Andersen: Which Is Right for You? (2026)

Scott Kingsley · Hannapel Specialist, Dowagiac · September 26, 2026

Same Family, Two Ways to Buy

If you have been shopping for replacement windows, you have probably seen both names and wondered whether they are the same thing. They are related, but they are not the same way to buy.

Andersen Corporation has been making windows since the early 1900s. In 1995, Andersen founded Renewal by Andersen as its full-service window and door replacement division. Renewal by Andersen sells directly to homeowners, usually starting with an in-home or virtual consultation, and its own crews handle the installation.

Andersen windows, on the other hand, are sold through independent dealers and showrooms. That is where Hannapel fits in. We have been in business since 1967, and we sell Andersen windows and doors from eight showrooms across Southwest Michigan.

I like to be straightforward with people, so here it is: both routes get you a window from a respected manufacturer. Neither one is a knockoff. The real differences are in what you are choosing from, who installs it, and what you pay.

Andersen Dealer vs. Renewal by Andersen: Side by Side

Sources: Andersen’s Andersen vs. Renewal by Andersen page, Andersen’s warranty comparison, and Renewal by Andersen’s cost explainer.

Why the Dealer Route Usually Costs Significantly Less

This is the part most homeowners care about, and the numbers are hard to ignore.

• Renewal by Andersen, per window installed (HomeGuide estimate)$1,500 – $5,000
• Andersen 100 Series, per window installed (HomeGuide estimate)$400 – $1,500
• Andersen Fibrex windows, Hannapel installed planning allowance$800 – $1,200

The national figures come from HomeGuide’s Andersen cost guide. Our allowance comes from our Southwest Michigan window cost guide. All of these are estimates, not quotes. Your price depends on sizes, styles, glass, trim and how the windows are installed.

Here is what that means on a typical 10-window house:

So why the gap? It is mostly about how each route is set up, not about one company being better than the other:

• Bundled vs. separate pricing. Renewal by Andersen’s price covers the window, the in-home consultation, measuring, project management and installation all together. Through a dealer, you pay for the window and the installation separately, and you can see exactly what each part costs.
• You pick the series. Renewal by Andersen offers its own line of Fibrex replacement windows. Through a dealer, you can choose Andersen’s 100 Series, which is also made with Fibrex composite, or step up to the 400 Series or A-Series only where your house calls for it.
• You pick the installer. Whether it is an installer we connect you with or the contractor you already trust, you can compare installation pricing instead of accepting one bundled number.

To be fair, the bundled price does buy something real: one company handles everything from the first appointment to the final cleanup, and the installation warranty comes from the same company. Some homeowners value that and are happy to pay for it. For everyone else, the dealer route puts a lot of money back in your pocket.

Is Renewal by Andersen’s Fibrex Window the Same as the Andersen 100 Series?

Not exactly. Both are made with Andersen’s Fibrex composite, a blend of wood fiber and thermoplastic polymer, but they are separate product lines with their own designs, options and sizing. Renewal by Andersen windows are custom sized to 1/16″ and built specifically for replacement. The 100 Series comes in standard sizes plus custom sizes to 1/8″, and it works for new construction as well as replacement.

What that means for you: if you like the idea of a Fibrex window, you can get one through a dealer too. If you want a wood interior or more design options, the dealer route opens up the 200, 400, A-Series and E-Series as well. Our Andersen series comparison walks through each one.

When Each Option Makes Sense

Questions to Ask on Any Window Quote

Whichever route you are leaning toward, these questions make quotes easier to compare side by side:

1. What exact product and series is this? “Andersen” alone does not tell you much.
2. What is the price per window, and what is the installation cost? Ask for it itemized.
3. What does installation include? Removal, disposal, flashing, insulation, interior and exterior trim, and finishing.
4. Who is doing the installation, and how long is the installation warranty?
5. What are the NFRC ratings for the glass package being quoted? Lower U-factor is better in our climate.
6. Can I take this quote home? A good price will still be good after you have had time to compare. For purchases made in your home, the FTC’s Cooling-Off Rule generally gives you three business days to cancel.

How Buying Andersen Through Hannapel Works

1. Visit a showroom. See the 100, 200, 400 and A-Series side by side, open and close them, and look at colors, hardware and glass options. Find the location nearest you.
2. Get an itemized quote. We price your windows by opening, so you know exactly what you are paying for.
3. Choose your installation. We can help connect you with a local installer, or your own contractor can install.
4. Get support after the sale. Our team includes an Andersen Certified Dealer Service Representative, so service and warranty questions stay local.

The Bottom Line

Renewal by Andersen and Andersen dealers both sell good windows from the same parent company. The difference is the buying model. Renewal by Andersen bundles everything into one premium price. Buying through a dealer gives you more window choices, more control over installation and, for most homeowners, a significantly lower total cost.

If you are replacing windows in Southwest Michigan and want Andersen quality without the bundled price, come see us. I am happy to walk you through the options, candidly, and help you figure out what makes sense for your house and your budget.

FAQ